Originally published September 29, 2007, as “The SEO Notebook, Pt. 1.” Rewritten November 2026.
My first post about SEO opened with Wikipedia’s definition and the line “No, I am no expert.” Fair enough in 2007. Today I’d rather give you the definition I actually work from.
SEO, or search engine optimization, is the work of helping search engines find and understand useful pages so the right people can reach them through unpaid search results. In practice, it means understanding what searchers need, creating the right content, organizing and linking pages, keeping the site technically accessible, and reviewing what happens.
That 2007 notebook came out of my day job doing content and site optimization for an Australian online retailer. The clearest lessons came from managing a team of about five writers for an Australian online pet retailer: briefs, product descriptions, and a lot of customer questions about fleas, shedding and collars.
Three Key Takeaways: What Is SEO
- SEO is more than keywords. Google’s SEO Starter Guide describes it as “helping search engines understand your content,” which covers how pages are organized, linked and crawled as well as the words on them.
- The page should match what the searcher is doing. A reader learning about dog collars needs a different page from a reader ready to buy one in the right size.
- Good SEO writing had standards long before AI. My pet retail team worked from briefs that asked for straight answers, links to credible sources and a controlled dose of brand personality.
What Does SEO Work Look Like in Practice?
SEO work runs in a loop: learn what people need and how they ask for it, create or improve the page that answers it, make sure search engines can reach and understand that page, connect it to related pages, then review what happens and adjust. Content is the most visible part of SEO, not the whole job.
- Understand the need. Start with the questions people ask, how much they already know, and what the current answers leave out.
- Build the right page. An explainer, a comparison or a product page, depending on what the reader is trying to do.
- Make it reachable and connected. Google’s SEO Starter Guide says “the vast majority of the new pages Google finds every day are through links,” and recommends organizing a site “in a logical way.”
- Review and adjust. Search Console shows how your pages perform in Google Search, so you can decide what to fix next. My minimum viable SEO stack covers what Search Console and GA4 can tell you for free.
If your SEO plan is only a keyword list, you’ve planned one step out of four. And no step comes with a guarantee. Google’s own guide puts it plainly: “There are no secrets here that’ll automatically rank your site first in Google.”
The Assignment Changes With the Customer’s Question
The right page depends on what the searcher is trying to do. Someone learning about a problem needs an explainer, someone weighing two options needs a comparison, and someone ready to buy needs a clear product page. Matching the assignment to that intent does more than repeating every keyword variation.
Here’s how that plays out with one product. These are illustrations, not a past campaign, and a single search can mix more than one intent.
| What the reader is doing | Example question | The page that fits |
|---|---|---|
| Learning | What should I consider when choosing a dog collar? | An explainer that walks through the decision factors |
| Comparing | How do these two collars differ? | A comparison of verified features and who each one suits |
| Buying | Where can I buy this collar in the right size? | A product page that answers size, price, availability, delivery and returns |
Google’s ranking systems guide explains why intent matters more than exact repetition. It says BERT helps Google understand “how combinations of words express different meanings and intent,” and RankBrain helps it understand “how words are related to concepts.” That’s why a separate paragraph for every keyword variation is a weak model of SEO.
Keywords haven’t stopped mattering, though, because relevance hasn’t. The Starter Guide still tells you to “think about the words that a user might search for,” and points out that people who know a topic well may search with different keywords from beginners.
Renzie’s Take:
People assume early SEO writing was all keyword stuffing. My team’s briefs asked for helpful, straightforward answers, full coverage of the topic, links to authoritative sources and just enough brand personality.
The editorial standards were already there.
What I’d change is the aim. Less effort on keyword variants, more on who the reader is and how close they are to a decision. Write naturally for real customers, and plan each assignment around what they’re trying to do.
What I Would Keep, and What I Would Change
I’d keep the briefs, the editorial standards and the habit of writing naturally for real customers. I’d change where assignments start: with real questions, customer problems and gaps in the answers already out there, instead of a list of keyword variants. Keyword tools would back that research up, not drive it.
Keep:
- Briefs with a clear structure and scope
- Helpful, straightforward answers
- Links to credible sources
- Natural writing for real customers
Change:
- Start with the questions people actually ask, from search results, discussions, reviews and customer enquiries
- Check what the existing answers miss before assigning a page
- Tell the writer the reader’s intent and the next useful step
- Use keyword tools as supporting evidence, not as the starting point
The research starts with the audience and what they still can’t find an answer to. A question that keeps coming up is a strong signal, but it isn’t a search-volume estimate, so treat it as evidence, not a forecast. For the full method, here’s how I do keyword research in the age of AI. For the longer story of what has and hasn’t changed since that first notebook, see what I’ve learned from doing SEO since 2007.
The Bottom Line: Match the Page to the Person Searching
- Start with the reader’s question, not a keyword list.
- Build the page that fits the intent: explain, compare or help them buy.
- Make the page reachable and connected, then review what happens.
Before your next assignment, finish this sentence: “The reader is trying to ___; this page will help them ___.” Then pick one existing page and check whether it actually does that job. When you’re ready to judge whether it’s working, read is your blog content doing its job? The rest of my process lives in the content writing system I use to stay consistent.


